Hiring Guide: Choosing the Right HOA/POA Manager for Your AssociationRunning a homeowners association (HOA) or property owners association (POA) well requires more than volunteer enthusiasm — it requires professional management. Choosing the right HOA/POA manager can protect property values, ensure rule compliance, streamline operations, and reduce conflict. This guide walks you through the hiring process, highlights essential qualifications and duties, and gives practical tools for evaluating candidates so your board can make an informed decision.
Why a Professional Manager Matters
A skilled manager brings experience in budgeting, vendor management, legal compliance, communications, and conflict resolution. They act as the operational backbone of your association, allowing volunteer board members to focus on policy and long-term strategy rather than day-to-day tasks. With the right manager, associations typically see improved financial controls, faster resolution of resident issues, and more consistent enforcement of governing documents.
Define the Role Clearly: Manager vs. Management Company
Before recruiting, decide whether your association needs an individual on-site/community manager or a full-service management company. Key distinctions:
- Individual/community manager: Often provides hands-on, on-site presence, familiar with daily community operations, resident relations, and small-vendor coordination.
- Management company: Offers a team with specialized functions (accounting, legal liaison, maintenance coordination, compliance officers) and scalability for larger or multiple associations.
Create a detailed job description and scope of services that include responsibilities, reporting structure, performance metrics, and budgetary authority.
Essential Qualifications and Experience
Look for candidates or firms with:
- Proven experience managing communities similar in size and complexity.
- Knowledge of state and local laws that govern HOAs/POAs, including fair housing and collections.
- Strong financial management skills: budgeting, reserve studies, accounts payable/receivable, and financial reporting.
- Vendor procurement and contract negotiation experience.
- Good communication skills for interacting with boards, homeowners, vendors, and local authorities.
- Professional certifications such as PCAM (Professional Community Association Manager), CAM (Community Association Manager), AMS® (Association Management Specialist), or M-CAE; membership in CAI (Community Associations Institute) is a plus.
Legal and Compliance Responsibilities
A manager should ensure the association complies with:
- Governing documents (CC&Rs, bylaws, rules & regulations).
- State HOA/POA statutes and regulations.
- Local building, safety, and health codes.
- Proper records maintenance and handling of confidential homeowner information.
- Collections and enforcement procedures that follow due process.
Confirm that candidates understand boundaries between board authority and manager authority to avoid overreach or liability.
Financial Oversight and Transparency
Financial stewardship is critical. Ask about:
- Experience preparing annual budgets and conducting reserve studies.
- Monthly financial reports and key performance indicators the manager provides.
- Internal controls and fraud prevention measures (segregation of duties, dual-authority payments, audits).
- How they handle delinquencies, liens, and collections — including use of attorneys or collection agencies when necessary.
Require references and examples of financial reports from similar communities (redact homeowner data).
Operations, Maintenance, and Vendor Management
Evaluate a candidate’s approach to maintenance and vendor management:
- Preventive maintenance planning and work-order systems.
- Vendor selection, bidding processes, and contract oversight.
- Emergency response protocols (plumbing, HVAC, security incidents, natural disasters).
- Use of technology: property management software, resident portals, and mobile apps for work orders.
Request sample maintenance schedules and vendor contracts they’ve managed.
Communication and Community Relations
A manager is often the public face of the association. Assess:
- Communication style and tools: newsletters, email blasts, community meetings, websites/portals.
- Conflict resolution skills and experience handling homeowner disputes, board tensions, and sensitive issues.
- Ability to run efficient board meetings, prepare agendas, and draft minutes.
- Strategies for building community engagement and volunteer participation.
Ask for examples of difficult situations they resolved and communications they used (anonymized).
Interviewing Candidates: Key Questions
Use targeted questions to reveal practical competence and judgment:
- Describe your experience with associations of our size and type.
- How do you prepare and present monthly financial reports?
- Tell us about a time you resolved a major homeowner dispute or vendor failure.
- How do you handle overdue assessments and collections?
- What software/systems do you use for work orders, accounting, and resident communications?
- How do you ensure compliance with state HOA laws and our governing documents?
- What would you do in a major emergency (storm damage, fire, major infrastructure failure)?
Follow up with scenario-based questions to see how they apply policies and prioritize actions.
Checking References and Background
Verify integrity and performance:
- Contact at least three references: current or former boards, vendors, and homeowners if possible.
- Confirm tenure, scope of duties, responsiveness, and any disciplinary or legal issues.
- Run criminal background checks and, where lawful, credit or civil suit searches for firms or individuals responsible for finances.
- Check licensing or certification status required by your state.
Document findings and weigh them heavily in decision-making.
RFPs, Pricing Models, and Contract Terms
If hiring a management company, issue a Request for Proposal (RFP) that specifies:
- Community profile (units, amenities, budget, staffing needs).
- Required services and performance metrics.
- Submission requirements: sample reports, staffing structure, references, pricing model.
Common pricing structures:
- Flat monthly management fee (typical for full-service firms).
- Per-unit fee model.
- Additional fees for on-site staff, assessments administration, vote services, or special projects.
Negotiate clear contract terms for:
- Term length and termination clauses.
- Performance standards and penalties for underperformance.
- Insurance, indemnification, and limits of liability.
- Transition plan and data transfer at termination.
Onboarding and Performance Management
A strong start matters:
- Develop a 30-60-90 day onboarding plan with priorities (document transfer, vendor review, emergency contacts, budget review).
- Set measurable performance metrics (timely financials, response times, maintenance completion rates).
- Schedule regular board-manager reviews and annual performance evaluations.
- Require training on your governing documents and community-specific issues.
Red Flags to Watch For
- Lack of relevant references or short tenures at past positions.
- Poor financial controls, unwillingness to provide sample financials or references.
- Vague answers about legal compliance or enforcement processes.
- Overpromising quick fixes or offering services beyond the board’s authority.
- Poor communication skills or inability to provide clear reporting examples.
Final Steps: Decision & Vote
- Shortlist top candidates and conduct final interviews with key board members.
- Verify contract terms and confirm insurance and bonding.
- Present the recommended candidate and contract to the full board for a formal vote per your bylaws.
- Prepare a transition plan and announce changes to residents with clear timelines.
Hiring the right HOA/POA manager is an investment in community stability and property values. A thorough, structured selection process—combined with clear expectations, solid contracts, and active oversight—reduces risk and sets your association up for smoother operations and better community relations.
Leave a Reply